SUBSCRIBE NEWSLETTER
  • Change Language
  • English
  • Hindi
  • Marathi
  • Gujarati
  • Punjabi
  • Tamil
  • Telugu
  • Bengali
  • MF News Jharkhand High Court hears commission disclosure appeal against SEBI

    Jharkhand High Court hears commission disclosure appeal against SEBI

    The next hearing is scheduled on November 8.
    Ravi Samalad Oct 31, 2016

    The next hearing is scheduled on November 8.

    Ranchi based distributor Priyanka Maheshwari, Director of Vedant Asset Advisors has filed an appeal against SEBI’s commission disclosure circular in Jharkhand High Court. The appeal was filed on September 29 and the court has accepted the appeal.

    The case was heard by the court last month and the next hearing is scheduled on November 8.

    “The regulator has replied to our appeal. We have appealed to the court that disclosing commissions is not fair and it is against the interests of distributors. It is in violation of our constitutional right to do business,” says Lallit Tripathi, Founder of Vedant Asset Advisors.

    Lallit says that disclosing commissions will not help investors take an informed decision and it can lead to passback practices.

    In its circular dated September 20, SEBI had asked AMCs to disclose the absolute commissions paid to distributors in half-yearly consolidated account statements (CAS) sent to investors. The circular has come into effect from October 1 and investors have already started receiving CAS.

     SEBI’s circular has also been challenged by United Forum, a federation of IFA Associations. The forum has filed an appeal with Securities Appellate Tribunal (SAT).

     

    Have a query or a doubt?
    Need a clarification or more information on an issue?
    Cafemutual welcomes all mutual fund and insurance related questions. So write in to us at newsdesk@cafemutual.com

    Click to clap
    Disclaimer: Cafemutual is an industry platform of mutual fund professionals. Our visitors are requested to maintain the decorum of the platform when expressing their thoughts and commenting on articles. Viewers are advised to refrain from making defamatory allegations against individuals. Those making abusive language or defamatory allegations will be blocked from accessing the web site.
    48 Comments
    Satish · 7 years ago `
    No business disclosing their purchase price,
    If they disclose buyer will not buy.its unethical forced rule by Sebi.

    Similarly direct plan also unfair to distributors.

    In world their r two chain
    Whole seller chain and retailer chain .

    Individual buyer not allowed to buy from whole seller chain.

    Here our great thinker ALBERT IENSTEEN SEBI allow investors buy direct scheme from whole seller chain that is Karvy, cams, AMC.

    If they want to sell direct plan Sebi has to open separate retailer chain.

    Get success in this case , I will file next
    Satish · 7 years ago `
    No business disclosing their purchase price,
    If they disclose buyer will not buy.its unethical forced rule by Sebi.

    Similarly direct plan also unfair to distributors.

    In world their r two chain
    Whole seller chain and retailer chain .

    Individual buyer not allowed to buy from whole seller chain.

    Here our great thinker ALBERT IENSTEEN SEBI allow investors buy direct scheme from whole seller chain that is Karvy, cams, AMC.

    If they want to sell direct plan Sebi has to open separate retailer chain.

    Get success in this case , I will file next
    narender singh rawat · 7 years ago `
    thank you vary much lalit ji
    Lokesh · 7 years ago `
    Well-done Mr.Ravi Somala...
    Can SEBI tell which are the other plan or any product selling like that anywhere in India?
    Lokesh · 7 years ago
    I am sorry it's Priyanka Maheshwari..
    Reply
    SARBESH Srivastava · 7 years ago `
    Very good step thanks for lalitjee
    Investment advisory solutions · 7 years ago `
    Thank u Mr Lalit Jee for taking the good step.
    Vinay jaiswal · 7 years ago `
    Thanks lalit sir .I support u
    mohd arif · 7 years ago `
    Well done,All the best, Mr.Lalit
    Ashok Kumar · 7 years ago `
    Thanks for taking a good step
    S.Rajasegarane · 7 years ago `
    Disclosure of income is not fair, pl implement in all are of insurance , investment etc to disclose of income and to stop trail commission, for Advisors this is bread winner of family income, I asking one think why AMFI, NSC,NISM for all certificates course there is the valid 3 yrs period, because of earning continuos income for collecting fees and to run the organization at long term run only your fixing the course as valid for 3 yrs and without any knowledge updating your collecting fee for renewel , all Advisors are updating date today life, so the up-front and trail commission like that only, SEBI pl stop this as early as possible , pl give life to the Advisor
    Padeep · 7 years ago `
    Great Lalit. While we were crying on whatsapp, you took an effective step for all of us on your own. You are right that investor is concerned with TER (his cost) and not in one variable component of TER(commission) and above all he is more concerned with net return for a unit of risk taken. Disclosure of advisors commission only and not TER appears malicious intention of SEBI.
    srikanth · 7 years ago `
    Very good, initiative at least some body to hand hold us.
    SANTOSH KR jha · 7 years ago `
    Very good step for ifa
    We r with u
    suresh · 7 years ago `
    Sebi should tell the investors that buying a GILT funds will Lower TER and commission to distributor better then buying a short term duration funds with higher TER nd higher commission or not . after all its all about cost baby #Crazy Regulator. # Be the REGULATOR not the player in mutual funds ...
    suresh · 7 years ago `
    May be The REGULATOR do not understand anything apart from mutual funds.All experiments in mutual funds. Failed regulator.. Get professional people in SEBI not Govt employee..
    Dikshant pande · 7 years ago `
    Is it good start we want to meet SEBI mr Sinha along with IFA association and talk to about Commission disclosure or RIA distribution rull. Is it negative impact in IFA career
    ashok kumar motwani · 7 years ago `
    Very good and brave step
    bimal misra · 7 years ago `
    i do heartedly support your porcess of appeal.thanks.
    Ajay · 7 years ago `
    Any update on this?
    Login or Sign up to post comments.
    More than 2,07,000 of your industry peers are staying on top of their game by receiving daily tips, ideas and articles on growth strategies. Join them and stay updated by subscribing to Cafemutual newsletters.

    Fill in the below details or write to newsdesk@cafemutual.com and subscribe to Cafemutual Newsletter now.