SUBSCRIBE NEWSLETTER
  • Change Language
  • English
  • Hindi
  • Marathi
  • Gujarati
  • Punjabi
  • Tamil
  • Telugu
  • Bengali
  • MF News FIFA to approach SEBI on upfront commission ban

    FIFA to approach SEBI on upfront commission ban

    FIFA Chairman, Dhruv Mehta said that they would request SEBI to reconsider its decision on banning upfront commission.
    Team Cafemutual Sep 19, 2018

    The Foundation of Independent Financial Advisor (FIFA) will soon approach SEBI requesting them to reconsider its decision on banning upfront commission and reducing TER.

    FIFA Chairman, Dhruv Mehta told Cafemutual that they would approach SEBI on the issue of upfront commission and TER reduction. He said, “The federation believes that the move will challenge the existence of small IFAs. Currently, close to 30,000 IFAs manage AUM of less than Rs.1 crore. These IFAs are hardly earning Rs.10,000 to Rs.15,000 per month. A hit of 20% on their earnings is a big blow to them.”

    Mehta further said that the move would also affect retail investors. “In my view, the cost of servicing retail investors has now gone up. It is not viable for many distributors to service investors investing up to Rs.10 lakh as distributors end up spending more money to acquire such clients.”

    In a letter sent to SEBI before its board meeting, FIFA had said that reduction in TER could affect earnings of IFAs. The federation had said, “Many small investors have just started investing in mutual funds over the last couple of years. If you reduce expense ratio, that would mean a reduction in earnings for IFAs. This in turn will harm small investors as the earnings out of their investments will make it unviable for IFAs to service and handhold them.”

    Have a query or a doubt?
    Need a clarification or more information on an issue?
    Cafemutual welcomes all mutual fund and insurance related questions. So write in to us at newsdesk@cafemutual.com

    Click to clap
    Disclaimer: Cafemutual is an industry platform of mutual fund professionals. Our visitors are requested to maintain the decorum of the platform when expressing their thoughts and commenting on articles. Viewers are advised to refrain from making defamatory allegations against individuals. Those making abusive language or defamatory allegations will be blocked from accessing the web site.
    45 Comments
    Sumit · 5 years ago `
    Now many IFA shift their investor investment to ulips , this will surely leads to misselling and effect the mutual fund industry badly
    Jogendra singh thakur · 5 years ago `
    Very nice steps by FIFA
    Ajay Sharma · 5 years ago `
    Only court Interance save our interest
    RANJAN · 5 years ago `
    It is very good thinking by FIFA. I suggest FIFA not to stop at just request level if SEBI fail to understand the plight of small IFAs and the resultant loss to small investors. If positivity will not come then FIFA should approach Security and Exchange Tribulal or higher authoritis
    Amit joshi · 5 years ago `
    Very well said mr rajeev gupta ji, sebi wants ifa to out from this business wants to sell through bank policy bazar paytm amazon... To make their capital value they are not earning from mutualfund they are not advising just making their customer base. All ifa should unite under any banner may be fifa and oppose in to regulator. Can be like business band ....No application submitted to registrar...No new business.
    Vineet · 5 years ago `
    Sebi is seeing the growing number and volume of SIP, growing number of MF investors but they dont see the reason behind it.. Technology cannot be a substitute to an advisor.. Sooner or later everyone will understand that behind the Mobile App or a Website, web application there is a program running which is designed by the owner of that platform and the result generated by such apps or website may be biased and rigged.. human intelligence and personalised approaches can Never be substituted.. I have been a part of this industry since 15 years and back then people used to think MF as Cheat Funds.. we literated people regarding it and are responsible for the figures we see in SIP and number of investors.. If the regulator doesnt see us or keeps on imposing such Anti IFA policies I am afraid that this growth story may be reversed very soon..
    RANJAN · 5 years ago `
    Very good decision by FIFA. I failed to understand why SEBI is interfaring in the business model of AMCs . Mutual fund is a business for them. Does Reserve Bank interfaring the interest rates offered by different banks on FD or loans? Banks are deciding on their own. SEBI being regulator has the power to overview whether AMCs are operating their business on prescribed lines. When SEBI opened many routes for investors to invest in Mutual fund then why it is worried about them. Why SEBI is not worried about GROWTH of Mutual funds in india. Upfront commission is a must for IFAs. For example if an IFA gets an investment of 1 lakh and upfront commission is .80 % then he supposed to get Rs.800. Now let us think that he spends 500 for acquiring that business. If Mutual fund will pay in trail model he has to get only Rs.65 per month. To recover his expenses it will take one year. How it is practical to finance this from pocket. In the meantime if due to requirement of money the investor takes away the money after 6 months then IFA will be in loss
    .
    Kulendra Bhaisal · 5 years ago `
    Very important initiative. Firstly Banks should be bared by the Government /SEBI from distribution of Mutual Funds. Only Individual IFAs should be allowed. In terms of Service nobody other than a IFA can deliver the same.
    Mehul · 5 years ago `
    With upfront and trail, churning used to happen on 366th day just to qualify for foreign trips. A good decision by SEBI. Now AMC ( manufacturers ) will make money as mostly upfronting was done from the AMC pocket and not charged to TER. A few AMC have " only trail " model since past few years.. like FT. There are many more improvements needed to be done by SEBI.
    Shailesh Gadbil · 5 years ago `
    FIFA is doing good work.Like few AMC's are also motivating clients to invest directly in mutual funds and SEBI is also trying to do so after taking this decision,but there should be both ways to invest directly or through Ifa it should be clients choice.
    G KARTHICK · 5 years ago `
    SEBI MUST PAY THE UPFRONT COMMISSION. EVERY YEAR RISE PRICE COST. FIVE YEARS BACK PETROL PRICE 60/- NOW RS 85-90 , SO INCREASE THE UPFRONT COMMISSION ALSO.
    SUNIL KUMAR TIWARI · 5 years ago `
    IT IS A VERY WORST MOVE BY SEBI AND EVEN AMC'S ARE ALSO NOT WILLING TO SEE THE LOSS OF IFA'S SPECIALLY SMALL IFA'S. IT IS THE MOVEMENT TO PROMOTE THE MNC'S AND OTHER CHANNELS INSTEAD OF PROVIDING SUBSIDY OR SUPPORT TO IFA'S THEY ARE PULLING THEIR LEGS. UPFRONT AND DISTRIBUTOR TRAIL COMMISSION IS VISIBLE TO THEM BUT INCREASE IN SALARY AND PERK'S OF AMC AS WELL AS REGULATORY BODY EMPLOYEES ARE NOT VISIBLE TO THEM. REDUCE THAT, TER WILL AUTOMATICALY REDUCE. PUT YOUR HANDS TOGETHER TO SUPPORT THE MOVE OF FIFA. DO NOT LET THEM BECOME WEAK. IT IS MY HUMBLE REQUEST TO ALL OF YOU. "
    Pranab · 5 years ago `
    Just ask official of SEBI & AMC team from top to bottom to contribute even one month salary for charity or better for Kerala flood victims,they will surely understand pain & suffering of IFA's who are made scapegoats for each & every changes in MF industry..firstly do away with entryload,then introduction of direct plan,online portals who just bluffs,levying of service tax now GST & now banning of upfront commissions...
    DEBABRATA SAHA · 5 years ago `
    START ONLINE TRADING BUSINESS, SCRAP MUTUAL FUND BUSINESS AND ASK ALL CLIENT TO GO TO SEBI OFFICE OR ANY BANK FOR SERVICING
    aMIT THAKKER · 5 years ago `
    A VERY GOOD DICISSION BY FIFA GO AHADE WE ALL IFA WITH Y I READ ABOVE VARIOUS COMMENT I REQUST ALL IFA COME TOGHER UNDER FIFA
    Login or Sign up to post comments.
    More than 2,07,000 of your industry peers are staying on top of their game by receiving daily tips, ideas and articles on growth strategies. Join them and stay updated by subscribing to Cafemutual newsletters.

    Fill in the below details or write to newsdesk@cafemutual.com and subscribe to Cafemutual Newsletter now.