SUBSCRIBE NEWSLETTER
  • Change Language
  • English
  • Hindi
  • Marathi
  • Gujarati
  • Punjabi
  • Tamil
  • Telugu
  • Bengali
  • MF News IFA associations across the country express concern over low commission rates

    IFA associations across the country express concern over low commission rates

    IFA associations of Kanpur, Ranchi and Kerala and have requested AMCs to absorb the cost of TER cut.
    Team Cafemutual May 18, 2019

    Kanpur’s Association of Mutual Funds Financial Advisors (AMFFA), Ranchi’s Mutual Fund Distributor Association (MFDA) and the all Kerala Association of Independent Financial Advisors (AIFA) have urged AMCs to absorb the cost of reduction in TER.

    These IFA associations have expressed their grievance against fund houses for not absorbing the cost of TER cut. These associations claim that their commissions have declined sharply after the implementation of the new TER slab.

    While the Kanpur association issued a memorandum of grievance against reduced commission structures, the Kerala body decided not to attend AMC meets and entertain AMC officials for new business. Similarly, the Ranchi’s association issued a press release to protest against low commission structure.

    Another IFA association in Bhagalpur, Bihar staged a demonstration against fund houses.

    Pavan Kumar Jaggi, President, AMFFA said that the mutual fund distribution business has become unviable for them. “Our association members cater to retail investors who do SIP of Rs.2,000 a month. If you calculate trail commission on this amount, it is hardly anything. On top of that, if you get reduced commission, how would you survive,” he said.

    Kerala IFA Sam Koshy said that a top fund house has sent an email to the Kerala association assuring them that they will look into the matter. Two other AMCs have also communicated verbally that they will address concerns. “While a top fund house has assured that they will absorb 90% of the TER cut, another fund house said that they will completely absorb the extent of TER cut,” claims Sam Koshy.

     

     

    Have a query or a doubt?
    Need a clarification or more information on an issue?
    Cafemutual welcomes all mutual fund and insurance related questions. So write in to us at newsdesk@cafemutual.com

    Click to clap
    Disclaimer: Cafemutual is an industry platform of mutual fund professionals. Our visitors are requested to maintain the decorum of the platform when expressing their thoughts and commenting on articles. Viewers are advised to refrain from making defamatory allegations against individuals. Those making abusive language or defamatory allegations will be blocked from accessing the web site.
    51 Comments
    Manas Paul · 5 years ago `
    My sincere request to all IFAS - Keep posting your concern & effect of shrinking revenue in your day today life. Don't just read this news and get away in a stable manner. Raise your voice for unjust & prejudice.
    Pramod Chaudhry · 5 years ago `
    Everytime whenever changes being made by SEBI always impacted IFA negetivily,no impact on AMC people,AMC people forget ,if distributors started Non Cooperation with MF industries,than think how many jobs will go.So my request to AMC officials to stand in favour of IFA so the MF industry could survive.
    Sivakumar n · 5 years ago `
    Sebi ordered total expense ratio, amc s to make more profit, they transfered ter cut to distributor head. So the villain behind the problem is amc s, not sebi. In country where, 3% market penetration 70%population in villages marketing cost, and follow up servicing cost very high. So present low penetration scenario ter cut is very much premature, and it will defenitely going to distroy targetted high market participation of common man. We need more than 10 lakh Holders to achieve this goal. But these kind of ter cuts actually reduce the number of ARN holders, and growth of public participation. So we need to fight against amfi in this regard. For that try to reduce AUMs from commission reducing AMC s, focus on small and new AMC s as they are willing to pay maximum.
    Manoj · 5 years ago `
    Need structured brokerage with scientific base and GST slab
    Pravin Kumar · 5 years ago `
    We need to discuss with SEBI and AMC and design incentive structure in such a way that it is lucrative enough for distributors to survive in this business and just enough for investors to bear the cost for running AMC. Also GST has to be a part of TER and should not charged to distributors.
    Dilip Kumar · 5 years ago `
    Why only IFA observe TER pressure. It should be spread in to AMC, employees, fund managers, CEO even entire industry because we all are doing work for our Indian public.
    Kundan kumar · 5 years ago `
    Due to Ifas, fund's aum grows and profit become bigger for AMC but expanse is same as it is in earlier stage. They should increase our trail, instead of increasing they decrease our trail cause reduction un ter. Missellings of direct plans without proper guidance and lack of services, clients exit in loss and they spread news that mf investment is not good. It is kind request to sebi pls stop AMCs to stop these type of practising.
    Kundan kumar · 5 years ago `
    AMCs should absorb the TER duduction. Due to IFA's efforts AUM size increase but their expanse don't increase, why don't they increase our trail that time from their increased profit.second thing Direct plans, AMCs missells direct plan without proper guidance and lack of services. It is kind request to sebi pls look into this matter and stop practising these things.
    santosh kumar · 5 years ago `
    Its better to move to other financial product which is easy to convince
    Prasanth krishnan · 5 years ago `
    Actually what these AMC's are thinking, are they think we are part time working member of we just doing MF business for fun ? They hold back our brokerage for nearly one month for a simple reason of software updation.. no idea how they are managing the large public money.. there are many people struggling at the time of school opening,, need to pay salaries to staff, office rent. Still all these problems are for low level IFA's.. I strongly believe it's because of that.. Amc is again holding cr& cr of money in their bank even with that interest they can pay 1000 IFA .. bullshit
    Shivkumar Kalra · 5 years ago `
    Banks are major problem. People prefer Banks for Mutual Fund Investment rather than any other medium. Also many people have expressed me that Banks tell their customer to not to visit independent MF Agent as they are not proper. Banks are proper source of Investment, Banks are big, Banks own big place, Banks are easily available. They are never closed. Their executives only passed one module and Banks say their executives are more sophisticated. And they regularly tell them if they go to independent MF Agent, they will be completely misguided and duped.
    Niladri Saha · 5 years ago `
    AMCs continue to increase profits at the expense of the IFA. With all round expenses on acquisition, hand holding, review, statutory compliance like GST,IT and services increasing the Regulators are drastically cutting down on our earnings. Also feel it is a step motherly treatment towards the Mutual Fund Industry and it's front line sales people., while the Insurance Industry players are left Scot free! No GST on Insurance commissions too. Clearly Direct is being aggressively promoted. First increase Financial awareness and then push Direct. In such a vast and diverse country like India, we have miles to go for this.

    Request every IFA Association across the length and breadth of the country to take this up. Unity will eventually win.
    B Apparao · 5 years ago `
    AMC's make profits quater on quarter, investor get returns respective asset class. What about IFAs? The way thinking SEBI and AMC's unfortunate.
    Sib Sankar Dey · 5 years ago `
    All the IFA S should be united against AMCs with your voices.
    Om prakash jaiswal · 5 years ago `
    It's over why nobody wants to understood that only ifa is provided real concern to their client either better investment product or tax planning and only commission from amc is our remuneration after 12-13 years in advisory bussiness we have faces many problems like direct, entry-load removel, claw back, gst but implementation of ter is killing now my income deployed by 40% after that and now I am not sure what will be the future of IFA
    Amit saxena · 5 years ago `
    ICICI & HDFC are the most dubious AMCs when it comes to transparency in brokerages. The staff is not able to calculate the brokerage & how the brokerage is arrived. Most of the AMCs are highly partial & biased in brokerage payment and treat Distributors on the basis of AUM , higher the AUM higher the rates plus below the table freebies. This is utmost shame . After 5 yrs I feel cheated & there is no ethics at AMC level.
    SUMIT ARORA · 5 years ago `
    Why cut in brokerage effect from previous AUM
    And AMC not increase our brokerage on previous AUM when he changed in ter and if we do new then brokerage is higher and same fund previous AUM brokerage is lower what is calculation
    Mukund onkar · 5 years ago `
    AMCs must absorb TER cuts. The new TER cut is killing IFAs. Is FM is aware of this??? Please intervene and sort out this issue and make AMCs payback whatever is deducted. AMCs are only thinking about their profits. Pls stop future business untill this issue is solved.
    Mukund Onkar · 5 years ago `
    AMCs must absorb TER cuts. The new TER cut is killing IFAs. Is FM aware of this or is sleeping???
    Why TER cuts old aums??? This is injustice to IFA community. IFAs suffering big time, Modiji please look into this issue and SEBI's guidelines. Please stop all future business till this problem gets sorted out.
    SPANDAN KUMAR BOSE · 5 years ago `
    THE BIG NAME AMCS ARE PLAYING WITH THE IFAS SENTIMENT MAY BE WE ARE THE BURDEN
    Vinod Choudhary · 5 years ago `
    The TER reduction and passing the same to the distributor is not merely a loss of income for us rather it's a slap on our profession. It says we distributors do not deserve it. We do not have the right to think anything big. Each time doing such things not only hamper our earnings but it majorly affects our moral and motivation of being loyal to envestors thinking about investors first and upscale our business.

    It's atrange to note that each and every AMC has got their own interpretations of SEBI circular. The earlier TER reduction has been intrpreted by HDFC, Reliance, ICICI and other big AMC as cut flat 20paise from the trail. While the UTI observed the change.
    IDFC interpreted it in other way the reduced the brokerage by percentage and 20% has been reduced means if i am earning 40paise from old AUM and 85 paise from new AUM then as per HDFC my new brokerage is 20paise and 65paise respectively while on the same business IDFC paying me 32 paise and 69 paise.

    How can a distrbutor believe that the AMC can think about us.
    Jitan · 5 years ago `
    Let’s follow the strategy of these big fund houses. Anyways they just have 1 good product each.

    Do a Tit fo Tat Strategy-
    Give them Only 0.5% of our total business to them going forward rather than boycotting them. This way, they will get some business as well as realization of their reducing relevance on a day to day basis.

    If the IFAs, NDs & banks have made them so big in terms of their size, they can also cut them to size over the next 3 years.
    Login or Sign up to post comments.
    More than 2,07,000 of your industry peers are staying on top of their game by receiving daily tips, ideas and articles on growth strategies. Join them and stay updated by subscribing to Cafemutual newsletters.

    Fill in the below details or write to newsdesk@cafemutual.com and subscribe to Cafemutual Newsletter now.