The apprentice MFD concept introduced by AMFI will harm the reputation of mutual funds and the distributor community, believes a majority of MFDs, shows a recent poll conducted by Cafemutual.
The poll asked our readers, which mostly comprise of MFDs, as to what they think of the concept. They had three options:
a. Will help the MF industry grow multi-fold and increase financial inclusion in India
b. Will have no significant impact as there are adequate distributors to serve people
c. Will have adverse impact on the reputation of MF and distribution community
Over 900 MFDs or 87% of the total respondents went with the third option. 10% voted for the first and 3% opted for the second choice.
The survey indicates that most MFDs are not in favour of AMFI's initiative. They say that the condition that apprentice MFDs can sell products of only a single AMC is not in the best interest of clients. This condition, they believe, will end up harming the reputation of the MFD community.
"Making apprentice MFD biased to only one AMC should be reconsidered in the best interest of clients," replied one MFD in our previous story.
"Such an MFD won't be able to do justice to client's portfolio by only offering funds of a single AMC. It might lead to mis-selling," said another.
However, there are many MFDs who have welcomed the move. We spoke to Sapient Wealth Chairman Dhruv Mehta, president of Pune MFD association Harshavardhan Bhusari, president of north India-based MFD association Sanjay Bhan, among other leading MFDs. All of them applauded the move but also shared some suggestions. They called for higher pay for women apprentices and a longer stipend-paying period for all the apprentices.