SUBSCRIBE NEWSLETTER
  • Change Language
  • English
  • Hindi
  • Marathi
  • Gujarati
  • Punjabi
  • Tamil
  • Telugu
  • Bengali
  • MF News ‘Let investors choose between distributors and RIAs’

    ‘Let investors choose between distributors and RIAs’

    North India based All Mutual Fund Distributors Welfare Association (AMDwA) recommends SEBI to let investors decide if they want to pay a fee.
    Daya Ragunathan Aug 4, 2017

    Responding to SEBI’s consultation paper on RIA, All Mutual Fund Distributors welfare Association (AMDwA) has expressed their concerns over segregation of investment advice and distribution activity.

    In an email sent to SEBI, AMDwA has pointed out that mutual funds have a penetration of only 4%. “To help increase penetration of financial products, investment advisors and distributors should be allowed to co-exist in the industry. This will give investors an option to choose the services they want based on their needs, social status, financial capability and comfort,” the mail says.

    Further, the association has said that SEBI should let investors choose between distributors and RIAs. “The investor must be allowed to choose if they want to pay separately for the advisory services or are happy with the existing model,” said the association. Simply put, the association has recommended SEBI to continue to allow distributors to provide incidental advice.

    The association has pointed out that in a country like India where the investors are not financially literate, putting a fee on advice might prompt investors to make unguided investments.

    “Investors may feel that expenses are being forced upon them; this may prompt them to avoid consultation altogether. This will eventually lead to loss of wealth due to over trading, over confidence and other behavioural biases,” said the mail.

    AMDwA has also recommended to SEBI to change the nomenclature of distributors from ‘Mutual Fund Distributor’ to ‘Mutual Fund Expert’.

    The AMDwA is a Delhi based advisor association with over 300 members across north India.

     

     

    Have a query or a doubt?
    Need a clarification or more information on an issue?
    Cafemutual welcomes all mutual fund and insurance related questions. So write in to us at newsdesk@cafemutual.com

    Click to clap
    Disclaimer: Cafemutual is an industry platform of mutual fund professionals. Our visitors are requested to maintain the decorum of the platform when expressing their thoughts and commenting on articles. Viewers are advised to refrain from making defamatory allegations against individuals. Those making abusive language or defamatory allegations will be blocked from accessing the web site.
    20 Comments
    Ajay Kumar Sharma · 6 years ago `
    Stop direct investments, Increase commissions , & simplify the OTM form
    kamal Manocha · 6 years ago `
    This is good thought.

    Just needs to be complemented with the mass-public awareness campaign that "Mutual Sahi Toh Hain, Par Free Nahi hai". So that investors are able to take an informed decision of selecting between an RIA or a Distributor. Otherwise, hidden fee spoils the level playing field. Isn't it?

    I urge cafe mutual to take this forwards ...
    kamal Manocha · 6 years ago `
    This is good thought.

    Just needs to be complemented with the mass-public awareness campaign that "Mutual Fund Sahi Toh Hain, Par Free Nahi hai". So that investors are able to take an informed decision of selecting between an RIA or a Distributor. Otherwise, hidden fee spoils the level playing field. Isn't it?

    I urge cafe mutual to take this forwards ..
    Arvind Thakur · 6 years ago `
    Stop direct investments, Increase commissions , & simplify the OTM form
    Hitesh sharma · 6 years ago
    Sahi ha
    Reply
    Arvind Thakur · 6 years ago `
    Stop direct investments, Increase commissions , & simplify the OTM form
    KD · 6 years ago `
    Completely agree, but main entities(like AMFI) need to avoid projecting distributor as Advisors.

    If AMFI can have a distributor corner on its home page then it should also have a corner for Advisors on its home page.

    After that let investor choose among RIA and Distributors.

    Ranjan dutta gupta · 6 years ago `
    It is irrelevant whether an Investor is having financial literacy or not. As a patient cannot be allowed to take purchase medicine from shop for his own treatment of illness without consulting the doctor in a similar way direct investment should be banned. Probably SEBI is not aware that many of the direct investors are burning their fingers with direct investments.The model of RIA can be successful only if direct investment will be banned.What SEBI is thinking about charging investors with a fee if they invest with RIA. But then what is the answer if an investor call on a RIA and discuss about investment schemes and ultimately not invest. Can RIA charge fee in that case? Better instead of introducing RIA model SEBI should start a very professional course for the distributors to upgrade their status in distribution business.
    Ekta Thaker · 6 years ago
    Like for tax filing we all go to C.A. , why cant we have one profession for all kind of financial advisory. Like CFP.
    Prashant · 6 years ago
    This will be same as RIA because compulsarily everyone will have to become CFP which again will be unfair and unjust to investors.
    Reply
    Lovish · 6 years ago `
    Golden Rule for investor to Decide which one to go with : Ask Distributor or RIA on what does he do for his investments? And, what does he do for his friends and family? I mean what % of family portfolio is in regular funds

    Golden Rule for Distributors : 100% of mutual fund portfolio must be in regular funds, with some allocation in popular category amongst distributors, i.e. capital protected funds. Same must be followed by distributors for their Friends and Family.
    Sanjay bhan · 6 years ago `
    Sebi should always consider the ground realty and don't be in hurry imposing regulations which will ultimately hurts the investors in the long run. There should be level playing field for everyone being Mfds or RIA or diffirent channels. Let's all grow mf industry together which we all are doing from last 2 decades. Good work AMDwA.
    Pradeep Singla · 6 years ago `
    Direct investment should be avoided as this neither good for investor nor for AMC MFD should be encouraged and promoted to guide properly so investment run for long as per client need and he makes money without any hassle
    Hunny Tarika · 6 years ago `
    I sometimes feel that SEBI is trying to finish off the middlemen in the industry .Is anyone in India ready to pay fees for Advisory? Past experience shows who does it? When so much of data is available on the net.
    Everyone in india is an advisor in his sense be it cricket or stock markets.
    Hunny Tarika · 6 years ago `
    I sometimes feel that SEBI is trying to finish off the middlemen in the industry .Is anyone in India ready to pay fees for Advisory? Past experience shows who does it? When so much of data is available on the net.
    Everyone in india is an advisor in his sense be it cricket or stock markets.
    Amit kumar · 6 years ago `
    Presently that situation is so pathetic. So pls stop direct commission, increased revenue model and simplify the comman application form along with otm form.
    Gulshan Kohli · 6 years ago `
    Mutual Funds are a Common Mans Simple Tool towards Financial Stability and are Mostly Bought after Personal Homogeneous Discussion between an Advisor & Investor. Hence there is a Bond of Mutual Respect, Understanding and a Sense of Responsibility within, where an Investor Looks upon an Advisor to Grow his Hard Earned Money without Charging any Advisory Fess. If SEBI breaks this system, whole Process of Financial Advisory will Collapse and Investors will be left High & Dry in a Complex Environment.
    If SEBI really wants to Improve the System, it should Strengthen AMFI Certification Process and put more Knowledge and Functional Responsibility on IFA Fraternity.
    Lovey mehra · 6 years ago `
    As a regulator rules should be prepared keeping in mind all kinds of investors benefit and not taking into consideration few. Sebi s own mutual fund campaign "mutual fund Sahi hai' and the mandatory disclaimer ' mutual fund are subject to market risk... ' itself point to the need of experts to exist for advice. Various options should co-exist so that investor can select as per their needs and comforts nothing should be forced upon. The reasons for low penetration of products without intermediaries and their optimum compensation should also be survived by the regulators.
    Tamanna Varma · 6 years ago `
    The financial literacy in our Country is too low and the Investor must be given a choice whether we wants to pay for the services availed or not. Both the models should exist.
    Prashant · 6 years ago `
    There are 2 things
    1) First of all the investors by enlarge will not want to pay fees and will prefer direct model both at the same time so it only and only benefits the AMCs and in future they will for sure be allowed to increase the expense ratios to make more money which actually should go to the distributors. So one entity earns at the cost of crores of investors and a lakh of distributors. So tgis is a malafide intention
    2) If investors oay fees they will hold RIA responsible for the performance of portfolio and everyone knows you don't need any expertise to become RIA but money. Now in that case will SEBI hold itself responsible since they are certifying and compulsorily making everyone pay fees and will the RIAs who fail will be responsible? Already RIAs have started losing their licenses. In that cases who will compensate investors? And has SEBI or the person or company wgo lost license compensated any one investor so far?
    So basically there are various reasons for SEBI to not bring RIA at all and keep the present system and actually increase the brokerage instead of reducing it to attract more prople to become distributors rather than bringing these AMC benefitting regulations.
    Login or Sign up to post comments.
    More than 2,07,000 of your industry peers are staying on top of their game by receiving daily tips, ideas and articles on growth strategies. Join them and stay updated by subscribing to Cafemutual newsletters.

    Fill in the below details or write to newsdesk@cafemutual.com and subscribe to Cafemutual Newsletter now.