SUBSCRIBE NEWSLETTER
  • Change Language
  • English
  • Hindi
  • Marathi
  • Gujarati
  • Punjabi
  • Tamil
  • Telugu
  • Bengali
  • MF News Individual MFDs and NDs command higher share in commission

    Individual MFDs and NDs command higher share in commission

    In FY 2021, they have commission to AUM ratio of 0.76 – 0.77%, shows draft IPO prospectus of Prudent Corporate Advisory.
    Abhishek Kumar Aug 25, 2021

    Individual MFDs and national distributors (NDs) have the highest commission to AUM ratio. Data shows that they make 76-77 paise for every Rs 100 worth of assets under their advisory.

    In FY 2021, NDs have a commission to AUM ratio of 0.77%. MFDs have the second highest ratio of 0.76%. Banks were at the bottom of the table with a ratio of 0.56%, shows data compiled by Prudent Corporate Advisory in its draft IPO prospectus.

    The commission percentage of distributors depend on the type of assets they sell. The commission for selling equity funds is higher than that of debt funds. Banks lag behind in % commission earnings as their AUM is debt heavy.

    There are other reasons too. Prudent said that quality of services and bargaining power play a role in deciding how much a distributor would earn as commission.

    "This (higher commission ratio of NDs and MFDs) can be largely attributed to them offering value added services such as personalised portfolio construction, customised client dashboard and the close connect they have with their customers leading to better customer experience. Also, there is a wide variation in the commission structure within the players of same category depending on the bargaining power and the operational asset class of the player," the document said.

    The industry's commission to AUM ratio was 0.65% in FY 2021. It was slightly lower in FY 2020 at 0.61%. The ratio was at its peak in FY 2018. In that financial year, individual distributors had earned over Rs.1 for every Rs 100 worth of assets under their advisory.

    Have a query or a doubt?
    Need a clarification or more information on an issue?
    Cafemutual welcomes all mutual fund and insurance related questions. So write in to us at newsdesk@cafemutual.com

    Click to clap
    Disclaimer: Cafemutual is an industry platform of mutual fund professionals. Our visitors are requested to maintain the decorum of the platform when expressing their thoughts and commenting on articles. Viewers are advised to refrain from making defamatory allegations against individuals. Those making abusive language or defamatory allegations will be blocked from accessing the web site.
    14 Comments
    Prashant · 2 years ago `
    Why are you behind distributor community is a big question in my mind. The table shows a different data and tour article says something else. How can you be so blind towards the truth? Banks earn highest commission from misselling all financial products which are third party meaning mutual funds and all kinds of insurance. Since they don't know how to do their own business and due to heavy corruption and their greed they are only and only misselling third party products which they should never be allowed to sell in the first place.
    Pankaj · 2 years ago `
    Banks have self made combo product of Loan+ Insurance, the fact is that borrowers are forced to buy traditional insurance product with the Loan amount.....RBI & IRDA must examine these issue.

    If an analysis is done of insurance policy buyer of Banks, most of them have been sanction loan too, question arise How one can effort huge amount policy premium who seek for loan amount.

    Insurance buyer has to take policy because loan may not been sanction if they do not opt it.

    So Regulator must play a fair role...


    Regards
    Pankaj Pancharia

    Rahul · 2 years ago `
    Dear Pankaj !!

    Wonderful information shared with investors community. This is time need to think twice invest through in MFD. This information shows only about industry average. Mostly MFD's earning commission more than 1.5%. It's my experience sharing with our investors community. One of MFD approach and advice about one mutual fund scheme. I checked in difference between Direct & Indirect expenses ration. It's shocking to me... difference between both is more than 1% ( this commission going to distributors pocket only). AMC business average income only 0.3%. MFD's earns more than 1.2% average in Vijag & Hyderabad. Thank you so much for Cafe Mutual. Always follow Cafe Mutual articles about industry trends all our mutual fund investors. We are appeal to SEBI ( request to central government give relax to individual investors shift indirect to direct schemes). Thank you so much once again Cafe Mutual and all direct mutual fund offer fintech companies...
    Hemant Goswami · 2 years ago
    If you can invest yourself, without the guidance of MFD, in direct funds then you must do that only. But when you become a MFD, you will come to know that how less people know about investing and how much wrong-selling banks and LIC and other life insurance agents are doing to them.
    MANOJ KUMAR SAHU · 2 years ago
    One mor thing i do not understand, no one is appealing that a LIC agent is earning aroun 30-35% commission on a policy issued that alos on teh basis of pure misselling. Nothing to do. When a new schme announced by LIC they just run behind customer aks them to take the policy eventhough that cusyomer already have 3-4 policies earlier. Why regulator keep eye on this and why these so called wise investors keep the LIC policies direct. Remember a wise MFD always analyse client's risk profile and advice a scheme and also from time to time review the scheme and make necessary changes. And i think for this effort he/she should deserve this pay .
    Reply
    Abdul · 2 years ago `
    Hi Rahul !!


    Thank you so much for providing valuable information. I am also got shock. I did check just now about difference between Direct & MFD through investment. I invested in small amc scheme every month Sip Rs40,000. My expenses ration is 2.50% Vs 0.3% direct scheme. I will stop immediately and do SIP directly with AMC. Thank you a lot for saving my money and special thanks to Cafe mutual. It's my request write a article about Direct & Indirect scheme investment information for investor community.
    Hemant Goswami · 2 years ago
    Can you tell me that scheme's name?
    Rahul · 2 years ago
    ITI Value Fund - ( MFD 2.62% & Direct Investor 0.32%).

    Dear Hemant !!

    I checked so many schemes.. There is lot of difference expenses ratio Direct & MFD. I am sharing my own experience with my follow investors. We are investor's community. It's our value money and looking for decent returns with less expenses.
    Rahul · 2 years ago
    ITI Small Cap Fund - Regular Plan means through MFD 2.57% (As on 31-Jul-2021)
    ITI Small Cap Fund - Direct Plan means direct Investment 0.32% (As on 31-Jul-2021)

    Source: Value Research

    My appeal to Cafe Mutual Team !!

    You guys are doing wonderful service to investor community. Can you write article about Direct & Indirect ( MFD & other channels ) ? Educate our investors community. It's SEBI given a powerful tool for all Indian Investors. Jai Hind India & Jai Hind SEBI & Cafe Mutual team.


    Regards
    Rahul
    Sunil · 2 years ago
    Mr.Abdul,

    If you are small investor and have SIP of 40000 per month in Small AMC where difference between expenses ratios is so huge then you seriously need to meet dedicated MFD not any regular.

    Thank you.
    Reply
    Hemant Goswami · 2 years ago `
    Story of a MFD: he goes to meet a client, pays Rs. 20 for a shared auto, reaches metro station, pays Rs. 60 for his destination metro station, from there whether he walks or pays for auto/rickshaw. So, suppose Rs. 100 is travel expense for one side and Rs. 200 for both sides. Suppose the client start a Rs. 1,000 SIP and MFD gets Rs. 1 for every hundred rupees. Now, you Mr Rahul and Mr Abdul can calculate how many months it will take to recover MFD's travel expense. And there are another expenses also like prints of forms, courier, phone call etc.
    Rahul · 2 years ago
    Dear Hemant !!

    This is information for every one. We always thanks to Cafe mutual and SEBI. They are doing their best to share knowledge with clients. It's our decision whether choose Direct or through MFD. I am not blaming any one in this system. In 2030, more than 80% AUM come under direct mode with less expenses ratio. Fact is always painful. I am sharing my experience and knowledge with other investors. Investors can make a right decision. Thank you so much wonderful fintech companies in India. It's my request before investing any mutual fund scheme check about expenses ration difference between Direct & MFD. Young generation will make wise decision. All the best for your business !!
    Anita · 2 years ago
    Then why sebi and amc took regular schemes ?
    Why they make fool to distributors ?
    Weather it was a plan to collect fund from market through distributors?
    What is the monthly dividend?
    When a business run they fleeing the distributors from the way ?
    Why they are not removing exit load from fund it should be for invested time like brokerage calculated.
    There many problem which need to short out both sebi and amc its not best practise
    Reply
    Yogesh Laddha · 2 years ago `
    The Difference is not only in different channel but Major is also from MFDs Base Slab to Higher Slab !
    Login or Sign up to post comments.
    More than 2,07,000 of your industry peers are staying on top of their game by receiving daily tips, ideas and articles on growth strategies. Join them and stay updated by subscribing to Cafemutual newsletters.

    Fill in the below details or write to newsdesk@cafemutual.com and subscribe to Cafemutual Newsletter now.