SUBSCRIBE NEWSLETTER
  • Change Language
  • English
  • Hindi
  • Marathi
  • Gujarati
  • Punjabi
  • Tamil
  • Telugu
  • Bengali
  • MF News ‘Government intends to grandfather till January 31, 2018’

    ‘Government intends to grandfather till January 31, 2018’

    Rakesh Santhalia, CFO, Karvy Computershare, discusses the impact of LTCG on mutual funds and its calculation.
    Team Cafemutual Feb 6, 2018

    Union Budget 2018 re-introduced long-term capital gains tax on sale of equity shares and equity MFs. While the re-introduction created anxiety, it is a solace that it comes with Rs.1 lakh threshold for exemption (capital gain amount) and provisions to grandfather the gains until January 31, 2018, says Rakesh Santhalia, CFO, Karvy Computershare. Here are FAQs to help distributors understand these provisions better.

    What is the applicable date for these provisions?

    Like most Budgetary changes, these provisions will also be applicable from April 1, 2018, after both houses of Parliament clear it and the President gives his assent. This means, all capital gains realised from April 1, 2018 will be attracting these provisions.

    Budget talks about Rs.1 lakh exemption. How is this to be calculated?

    Long-term capital gains realised from all transactions under sale of equity shares and equity MF schemes during the financial year will be aggregated. For example, if the total of the long-term capital gain is at Rs.2 lakhs in the financial year, then the investor has to pay LTCG tax of 10% on Rs.1 lakh only.

    What is grandfathering?

    Grandfathering means the exemption granted to investors on the gains made by them before the new provisions come into force. This is more of a comfort clause while migrating from an easier to a strict tax regime. The government intends to grandfather or exempt gains made until January 31, 2018.

    How does grandfathering work?

    If your investor sells stocks or equity mutual fund units held for over a year, on or after April 1, 2018, LTCG tax will be calculated on the basis of higher of 1) purchase price or 2) lower of (i) highest traded price or declared NAV in case of MFs, on January 31, 2018 or (ii) sale price. See the examples given below for better understanding. It should be noted that a “loss” scenario is indifferent to “grandfathering” provision.

    What if the equity share was not traded on January 31, 2018 or the MF scheme did not declare NAV?

    In that case, the traded price or declared NAV as on the immediately preceding date to January 31, 2018 is to be considered.

    Can we know about different scenarios and applicable LTCG tax impact?

    Scenario

    Stock / Equity MF units bought on 1st January 2017

    (A)

    Highest traded price or declared NAV on 31st January 2018

    (B)

    Sale Price on 2nd April 2018

    (C)

    Long-term capital gain

    Example 1

    Rs 100

    Rs 200

    Rs 300

    Rs 100 (‘C’ – ‘B’, as ‘B’ is higher than ‘A’)

    Example 2

    Rs 100

    Rs 50

    Rs 300

    Rs 200  (‘C’ – ‘A’, as ‘A’ is higher than ‘B’)

    Example 3

    Rs 100

    Rs 150

    Rs 125

    NIL (‘C’ – ‘C’, as ‘C’ is lower than ‘B’ and higher than ‘A’)

    Example 4

    Rs 100

    Rs 75

    Rs 90

    LTCG loss of Rs 10. (‘C’ – ‘A’)

     

    You can post any additional queries on this topic in the comment section below. We would be happy to respond to you to the extent possible. 

    Have a query or a doubt?
    Need a clarification or more information on an issue?
    Cafemutual welcomes all mutual fund and insurance related questions. So write in to us at newsdesk@cafemutual.com

    Click to clap
    Disclaimer: Cafemutual is an industry platform of mutual fund professionals. Our visitors are requested to maintain the decorum of the platform when expressing their thoughts and commenting on articles. Viewers are advised to refrain from making defamatory allegations against individuals. Those making abusive language or defamatory allegations will be blocked from accessing the web site.
    10 Comments
    vivek · 6 years ago `
    can you explain to me the grandfathering concept in detail
    Rakesh Santhalia · 6 years ago
    A grandfather clause is a provision in which an old rule continues to apply to some existing situations while a new rule will apply to all future cases. Those exempt from the new rule are said to have grandfather rights. In the present case, as a principle, the gains, accrued upto January 31, 2018, are proposed to be tax exempt and hence it is called as “grandfathered”.

    On a lighter side, when a kid is put on a strict situation by father (immediate guardian), sometime grandfather comes on the way and put veto to protect the kid. In the present case, government is protecting the taxpayers from tax on gain accrued until January 31, 2018.
    Reply
    amit · 6 years ago `
    why nil tax on scenario 3, it should have been capital loss
    Rakesh Santhalia · 6 years ago
    Gain = Sales (actual) - Cost (as per definition)
    The new proposed provisions has defined cost as higher of "Actual Cost" or "Highest traded price or declared NAV on 31st January 2018". However, if "Actual Sales Price" is lower than "Highest traded price or declared NAV on 31st January 2018" then "Actual Sales Price" shall be considered in place of "Highest traded price or declared NAV on 31st January 2018". In example - 3, Gain = Sales (Rs 125) - Cost (which would be higher of actual cost or sales price which is again Rs 125), hence it would be "Nil"
    Reply
    juhi · 6 years ago `
    How Long-term capital gains will be calculated if equity MF schemes units are switched to growth option on 01st April, 2018 for another 01(one) year, which were bought 1) on 15th of November , 2016; 2) on 15th of December , 2016; 3) on 15th of January and 4) on 15th of February , 2017. Explain wih an example.
    Rakesh Santhalia · 6 years ago
    Since the switch shall be done after 31st January 2018, the cost of acquisition for the units lying in “growth plan” (after switch) shall be NAV of this (growth) plan as on the date of switch. Assuming that currently the units are lying in equity MF schemes “income/dividend plan”, there is no relevance of the 4 different dates provided by you because the capital gain shall be calculated only from the date of switch to “growth plan”. For example, if switch is done on 1st April 2018 with NAV of Rs 50 and sold after one year i.e. on 2nd April 2019 with NAV of Rs 55, long term capital gain shall be Rs 5 and 10% tax shall be levied on such LTCG subject to overall exemption of Rs 1 Lakh in a year. In addition, Surcharge (if total income of beyond prescribed threshold) and Health & Education Cess @4%, shall also be applicable.

    From the date of purchase (4 dates mentioned in the query) of units under "income plan" till the date of switch to "growth plan", the investor would have earned dividend which is subject to dividend distribution tax & not capital gain tax.
    Reply
    Ramesh R Bhanusali · 6 years ago `
    How is the calculation done for Equity Shares or MF Equity scheme purchased before more that a year and is sold between February and March 31st 2018.Please explain if possible with example .
    Rakesh Santhalia · 6 years ago
    LTCG tax on sale of Equity Shares or MF Equity scheme is applicable only from April 1, 2018, hence long term capital gain arisen on sales of Equity Shares or MF Equity scheme between February and March 31st 2018, shall be tax free and no tax is payable
    Reply
    Mayank Bhatia · 6 years ago `
    IF a unit is purchased on 1/1/2016 @200 FMV on 31st Jan is @100 Sold for 125 what will it be Gain or Loss
    MAyank · 6 years ago `
    If a unit is purchased on 1/1/2016 @200 FMV on 31st Jan is @100 Sold for 75 what will it be the loss
    Login or Sign up to post comments.
    More than 2,07,000 of your industry peers are staying on top of their game by receiving daily tips, ideas and articles on growth strategies. Join them and stay updated by subscribing to Cafemutual newsletters.

    Fill in the below details or write to newsdesk@cafemutual.com and subscribe to Cafemutual Newsletter now.
    Cafemutual is an independent media platform and focuses on providing knowledge and information for the benefit of finance professionals. We do not promote any particular brand or asset category.